Tuesday, September 22, 2020

Devaluing books.

I have noticed that on PBS's Antiques Roadshow, two things that people often think will be valuable but aren't are old toys and old books. Even when a toy (in the original box!) is valued well, a revisit to an old episode with updated pricing usually shows a drop. For a book to be valuable it needs to be a first edition, of some historical interest, in perfect condition, with dust jacket (if applicable), and so on and so forth, and maybe it's a couple of hundred dollars.  

My concern isn't for the monetary value of books at the moment, though, but of their value in our culture.

Old Joke: How do you break a nerd's finger? Slam his book on his nose.

Before computers took over the world, books had a place of honor in the culture, a value that is lost now. I don't think those of us old enough to remember the pre-Internet days appreciate that. Before computer storage was common, books were the cheapest means of storing any kind of data. And before photography and phonography, putting things down on paper or the like was the only means of storing data. Printing was the only means of reproducing it for distribution.


For centuries books represented the depository of all human knowledge and wisdom. They commanded a respect that I think young people can only imagine. True, people who lived their lives in books, for research, writing, library science, and whatnot, could be teased as bookish or bookworms, but the respect engendered by books and what they meant usually rendered the teasing light.

All of a sudden, slowly when computer data storage began, then suddenly as the Internet blossomed into businesses and homes, books lost their place as the repository of all human knowledge. It happened so fast that we still haven't recovered from the cultural whiplash. 

In a historical trice, a whole category of books was wiped out. Print encyclopedias, trivia books, the full-length Guinness Book of World Records, sports data books, map books, all sorts of general knowledge books vanished or became shadows of their former selves. The Internet was faster, free, and with the smartphone, could fit in your pocket. Sites were never out of date because they could be updated to the current minute. Even if the information was wrong, it was good enough for most readers. And it's not like the old books were always 100% on the money, either. 

Books still have place in our culture anymore; it's just that their prestige has mostly gone. When everything is data, books are just more files to download. 

I think the main loss at this point is historical. Book lovers for the most part had a good sense of history and the continuity of human nature, because the minds of those in the past were still alive in their books. Today, dusty old books have as much respect from those who grew up the Internet as do dusty old Web sites. The Internet has led them to live in the eternal now. The idea of browsing in a used-book store for old forgotten treasures makes as much sense to them as buying old food. Most of those shops are long gone now, anyway.

No wonder these idiots rampage in the streets. Why would they have respect for our culture, our history? Nothing matters or even exists but this current second.

As always, I thank the fine folks at Gutenberg, such as our friend Mongo, for helping to keep the fires of civilization lit. How long we can hope to do that, who knows? The Internet is a wonderful genie, but once it's free from the bottle, you can't control what it does.

3 comments:

  1. Thanks for the mention, Fred. I miss the days of the small independently owned bookstores. We had one here in Rock Ridge that you could sell used books to and had inventory up to the ceilings. You could usually find something interesting, and could spend hours there. Stuff was available there that a retailer today wouldn't touch with a ten-foot pole.

    One of the things I enjoy about Gutenberg is that none of the texts are expurgated (yet). These days it doesn't take a great leap of the imagination to picture an electronic "Fahrenheit 451" scenario. Amazon and Google are leading the way already!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I suppose you get a pass since the bulk of the books were suitable for past times... except for any that deal with race, I'm sure. I don't know how to get the point that not wanting to burn books does not mean supporting their contents wholeheartedly. If civilization doesn't know where it comes from, why not erase the irrelevant past and declare year zero?

    I also loved the old bookstores, looking for particular items and enjoying the discovery of things unknown. There are precious few left, even in Manhattan.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Not to worry, come the massive EMP event, the internet will be toast and the few remaining books will be valuable again. If, that is, they aren't just valuable as tinder.

    ReplyDelete